Table E:  Fad vs. Substantive Change in Adult Literacy
 
CURRENT 
DIRECTION
POSSIBLE FAD?
or
SUBSTANTIVE
CHANGE
NOTES
RESOURCES
TO
CONSIDER
I.  "Historical Amnesia," otherwise known as Political Interest FAD -- can a politically correct view become a socio/educational commitment? 1960's=100,000 program 
1970's=Right To Read 
1980's=PLUS 
1990's=America 2000
Bush 
Bracey 
Clinton 
Duffy 
Kazemek 
King & Brozo 
Miklos 
Smith
II. The "Quick Fix" FAD--anyone can fix it Each one teach one. 
All you need is a degree in caring... 
Will we ever realize that adults probably represent more complex challenges, not fewer? 
 
Anderson 
Kazemek 
Roscow 
Smith 
Specter 
IRA resolution
III.  Professional Organizations Join the Bandwagon FAD fast becoming a substantive change CRA Adult Learning Div 
IRA Adult Lit committee 
   &  ALSig 
monographs - CRA, IRA
Clay 
Frager 
Newman & Beverstock
IV.  Linking with Volunteer 
Organizations
FAD fast becoming a substantive change LLI, LVA 
Professional-volunteer networks
Boraks & McLendon 
Frager 
Imel 
Richardson (88)
V.  Redefining the Adult Developing Reader FAD fast becoming a substantive change From the deficient "have nots" to the different "haves;" looking at literacy in a social context; empowerment & ownership Avilla 
Fingeret (83) 
Gabb 
King & Brozo 
Malicky & Norman 
Richardson (89) 
Richardson & 
Thistlethwaite 
Rose
VI.  Integrating Knowledge Substantive change Linguistics, CAR, whole language, psychology, technology, research... Askov & Clark 
Boraks & Richardson 
Gabb 
Keefe & Meyer 
Malicky & Norman 
Richardson & Thistlethwaite 
Siedow (1991)
VII.  Learner-based assessment Substantive change Less formality or standardization;
learner involvement
Finlay and Harrison
Heathington et. al.
Jackson
Jones&Parker 
Lytle & Wolfe
Metz
Thistlethwaite
This is Not a Test
VIII.  Qualitative Evaluation Substantive change Moving from competencies & standardized tests as stand-alone measures;
toward qualitative, inquiry approaches
Fingeret (83; 91)
Gabb
Lytle & Wolfe
Padak & Padak
Richardson (1981)
IX.  Specialization Substantive change Adult literacy comprises:  workplace; ABE, tutor training, corrections, intergenerational & family literacy, ESL... Collins
Cruz
Hansell & Voelkel
Mikulecky
Phillipi
Siedow
Stitch
 

for more information, read:
 
Richardson, J. S.  (1993). Fads or substantive change in the filed of adult  literacy?  in N. Padak & T. Rasinski (Eds.)., Inquiries in Literacy learning and 
Instruction.  Yearbook of the ,  27-37.